Building an Engaging Classroom through Thinking Tasks
Haimchandra Nandkumar, York College and Queensborough Community College
Bio
Haimchandra Nandkumar is an Adjunct Lecturer at Queensborough Community College and York College, where he teaches Health and Public Health courses. With more than 10 years of teaching experience, his academic background includes degrees in Chemistry, Mathematics, Health and Organizational Management, and a Master of Health Administration. He is currently pursuing a Doctorate in Health Science and Health Education and also holds several certifications in Medical Sciences and program training. His professional mission is to strengthen academic and organizational systems, support community wellness, and empower diverse populations through education, resilience-building, and informed health decision-making.
Course Setting
I work with both high school students and first-year college students who are beginning their academic journey in the health sciences and public health fields. Many of the students come from diverse cultural, educational, and socioeconomic backgrounds, bringing unique perspectives and experiences into the classroom. The courses I teach focus on introducing students to essential concepts in health sciences, healthcare systems, and medical communication. In HS 105 Medical Terminology, students learn the fundamentals of medical terminology, physiology, and pathology of the human body. In Public Health 102, students explore the foundations of health administration and organizational structure.
Problem of Practice
How might I increase student engagement to produce tangible outcomes in informal and formative assessments by the end of the lesson and improve student content mastery?Strategy
Visibly Random Groupings (VRGs) is a collaborative learning strategy from Peter Liljedahl’s framework, Building Thinking Classrooms. His research suggests that students should be placed into randomly assigned groups that are visible to the entire class. This approach ensures that students work with different classmates regularly, creating equal opportunities for participation, communication, and peer learning.
This strategy was implemented to increase student engagement, participation, and understanding of medical terminology through active learning and discussion. Research on collaborative learning suggests that students learn more effectively when they explain concepts themselves, solve problems together, and hear multiple perspectives from peers. VRGs also support critical thinking, teamwork, communication skills, and accountability while helping students build confidence in applying medical terminology in real-world healthcare situations.
Vertical Non-Permanent Surfaces (VNPS) is an active learning strategy that encourages students to collaborate while solving problems on vertical whiteboards or non-permanent surfaces. This approach promotes visible thinking, student participation, and real-time discussion among peers.
The purpose of implementing VNPS was to increase student engagement, strengthen communication and teamwork skills, and support deeper understanding through collaborative problem-solving. Research on active learning strategies suggests that students retain information more effectively when they actively participate in discussions and explain concepts to others. This strategy also exposes students to multiple perspectives and encourages accountability within groups. Additionally, working in groups using VNPS helps students develop critical thinking and collaboration skills that are essential in healthcare and public health team environments.
To measure student understanding and mastery, I incorporated informal and formative assessments throughout the lesson, including short quizzes, reading reflections, discussion questions, and end-of-class checks for understanding. Questions were designed to assess whether students completed the readings and understood key concepts. Students also received feedback regarding participation, academic progress, and classroom behavior.
Documentation
Students Working at Vertical Non-Permanent Surfaces
During the lesson, students worked in small groups at vertical boards to discuss medical terminology concepts, write responses, and explain their reasoning collaboratively. Students were encouraged to ask questions, share ideas, and revise their work together as they analyzed course content and patient-related scenarios.
Engaging Thinking Task
Students were placed into VRGs and asked to analyze medical terminology within patient scenarios. Each group identified prefixes and suffixes, determined possible causes of medical conditions, and explained the effects of those conditions on the human body. Students discussed their findings collaboratively and presented their reasoning to the class.
Measuring Impact
Quiz Grades: With and Without BTC Strategies
This graph shows individual student quiz grades from two sections that I teach. The same quiz was administered to each cohort. The cohort that utilized the VRG and VNPS strategies demonstrated significantly higher quiz outcomes.
Sample Student Feedback
Students provided very positive feedback about the strategies and frequently requested that these activities be used more often. This is one example representing student feedback.
Analysis
The implementation of Visibly Random Groupings (VRGs) and Vertical Non-Permanent Surfaces (VNPS) increased student engagement, collaboration, critical thinking, and participation. Student feedback reflected high engagement, with comments such as, “This was engaging,” and “I enjoyed writing and using the materials.” Real-world patient case studies helped students connect terminology to healthcare settings, making the lesson more meaningful and applicable. Students also strengthened their vocabulary analysis skills by identifying unfamiliar medical terms through word-part analysis rather than memorization. Many students demonstrated increased confidence and interest in participating and recommended more activities of this kind.
These strategies directly addressed my Problem of Practice (PoP), which focused on increasing student engagement while using informal and formative assessments to demonstrate student mastery by the end of the lesson. Students actively participated in discussions, analyzed medical terminology through patient scenarios, and collaborated to identify prefixes, suffixes, causes, and effects of medical conditions. Classroom observations, discussions, and student explanations demonstrated improved understanding of medical terminology and stronger critical-thinking skills.
The strategies also created an interactive and supportive classroom environment that encouraged communication and collaborative problem-solving. Formative assessments, observations, and student feedback indicated that some groups needed additional support and clearer guidance. As a result, I recognized the importance of providing structured prompts, defined group roles, clearer directions, and differentiated support to keep all students actively engaged throughout lesson activities.
Data analysis from the learning activity showed that students benefited from collaborative strategies, as quiz grades improved after students participated in the collaborative thinking tasks. During the activity, students demonstrated respect, cooperation, and active participation, contributing to a productive classroom environment. The task also reinforced the value of collaboration, communication, and teamwork while deepening students’ understanding of course concepts.
One challenge observed was that some groups needed additional guidance to identify the most important information within each patient scenario. In future lessons, I would provide clearer instructions, guiding questions, and structured group roles to keep all students actively involved and focused throughout the activity.
Recommendation
I would advise other CN or EC professors to use strategies such as Visibly Random Groupings (VRGs) and Vertical Non-Permanent Surfaces (VNPS) when teaching high school students in college-level courses because these approaches increase engagement, collaboration, communication, and critical thinking. High school students transitioning into college classes often benefit from interactive and structured learning activities that move beyond traditional lectures and encourage participation, teamwork, and problem-solving.
VRGs help students build confidence by working with different peers and learning from multiple perspectives, while VNPS encourages students to organize ideas visually and explain their thinking in real time.
Providing clear instructions, guided prompts, structured group roles, and formative assessments can further support accountability and understanding while helping students develop the communication, analytical, and teamwork skills necessary for academic and professional success.
Resources
- Liliedahl, P. (2021). Building thinking classrooms in mathematics: 14 teaching practices for enhancing learning. Corwin.
- Teaching Math – Visibly Random Groups
- The Magic of VNPS (Vertical Non-Permanent Surfaces)
- Saskatchewan Math – Vertical Non-Permanent Surfaces and Mini White Boards
- Free Random Grouping Cards for Visible Random Groupings
- Illinois Wesleyan University – VNPS Research Study